The problem with that is that HHH/Rock/Austin were arguably the biggest stars of their time(and possibly all time).

Problem is that CM Punk is a far bigger star right now than Batista has been, and is more over with the crowd than Batista.

If the match happened 2 years ago then yes it would be huge, but if it happened right now it wouldn't be right, as Punk is more over than Orton and Roidista.